Development of the model of the atom · describe
Ideas about what an atom looks like changed a great deal between about 1900 and 1935 as new experimental evidence was found.
Describe how the model of the atom developed over this time, and the evidence that led to each change.
Show the model answer
At first atoms were thought of as tiny solid spheres that could not be divided into anything smaller.
When the electron was discovered, this idea had to change, because atoms clearly contained smaller particles. The plum pudding model described the atom as a ball of positive charge with negative electrons spread through it.
Then scientists fired alpha particles at very thin gold foil. Most of them passed straight through, which showed that most of the atom is empty space. A few were deflected and a very small number bounced back. This showed there must be a tiny centre that is positively charged and contains most of the mass. This gave the nuclear model, with a small positive nucleus and electrons around it.
Niels Bohr then suggested that electrons orbit the nucleus at fixed distances, in energy levels. His calculations agreed with experimental observations.
Later experiments showed that the positive charge of the nucleus is made of smaller particles, called protons. About 20 years after the nucleus was proposed, James Chadwick found evidence for neutrons, which explained the extra mass in the nucleus. Each time, the model changed because new evidence did not fit the old one.
- before the electron was discovered, atoms were thought to be tiny spheres that could not be divided
- the discovery of the electron led to the plum pudding model: a ball of positive charge with negative electrons spread through it
- in the alpha scattering experiment, alpha particles were fired at very thin gold foil
- most alpha particles went straight through, showing that most of the atom is empty space
- a few were deflected and a very small number bounced back, showing a tiny, dense, positive centre
- this led to the nuclear model, with the mass concentrated in a small positive nucleus and electrons around it
- Bohr suggested electrons orbit the nucleus at fixed distances in energy levels, which matched observed results and theoretical calculations
- later experiments showed the positive charge of the nucleus is made up of smaller particles called protons
- Chadwick's work about 20 years after the nucleus was proposed gave evidence for neutrons in the nucleus, which accounted for the extra mass of the nucleus
- each model was replaced or changed because new evidence could not be explained by the old one
- 5-6 marks: describes the sequence from indivisible spheres to plum pudding, nuclear model, Bohr's energy levels, protons and neutrons, linking the key changes to the evidence, especially alpha scattering.
- 3-4 marks: describes at least two models in the right order with some evidence, for example plum pudding replaced after alpha scattering.
- 1-2 marks: names one or two models or describes the modern atom with no development.
- saying alpha particles bounced back because they hit electrons
- putting the models in the wrong order
- describing the experiment without saying what each result showed