Limiting factors · use the data
Oliver measured the rate of photosynthesis of a pondweed at different light intensities and at two concentrations of carbon dioxide. The temperature was kept at 25 °C.
| Light intensity in arbitrary units | Rate at low CO2 in bubbles per minute | Rate at high CO2 in bubbles per minute |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 6 | 6 |
| 2 | 12 | 12 |
| 3 | 15 | 18 |
| 4 | 15 | 24 |
| 5 | 15 | 26 |
Use the data to explain which factor limits the rate of photosynthesis at different light intensities.
Show the model answer
A limiting factor is the factor in shortest supply, which stops the rate of photosynthesis going any faster.
Between 1 and 2 units of light, the rate doubles from 6 to 12 bubbles per minute, and the two CO2 columns are identical. Adding more carbon dioxide made no difference, so light intensity is the limiting factor here. Light provides the energy needed for photosynthesis, so more light gives a faster rate.
At low CO2, the rate stops rising at 15 bubbles per minute from 3 units onwards. Increasing the light has no further effect, so carbon dioxide concentration has become the limiting factor.
At high CO2, the rate keeps rising to 24 bubbles per minute at 4 units. This proves that the low CO2 was holding the rate back in the other experiment.
At 5 units, the high CO2 rate only rises from 24 to 26, so it is starting to level off. This suggests another factor, such as temperature or the amount of chlorophyll, is starting to limit the rate.
- a limiting factor is the factor in shortest supply that stops the rate increasing
- from 1 to 2 units the rate doubles from 6 to 12 at both CO2 levels
- at low light intensities the two columns are the same, so light intensity is the limiting factor
- light provides the energy for photosynthesis, so more light means a faster rate
- at low CO2 the rate levels off at 15 bubbles per minute from 3 units
- here increasing light has no effect, so CO2 concentration is limiting
- at high CO2 the rate carries on rising to 24 and 26
- this shows the extra CO2 removed the limit set at low CO2
- at high CO2 the rate begins to level off at 5 units, so another factor, such as temperature or chlorophyll, may be starting to limit
- 5-6 marks: uses figures from the table to identify the limiting factor at low and at higher light intensities for both CO2 levels, with reasons.
- 3-4 marks: identifies light as limiting at first and CO2 as limiting later, with some data, but explanation is incomplete.
- 1-2 marks: describes a trend, such as more light gives a faster rate, with no idea of a limiting factor.
- describing the numbers without naming the limiting factor
- saying light is limiting where the rate has levelled off
- not quoting any figures