Aligned to AQA Combined Science 8464 and AQA GCSE Biology 8461
5 original questions, 6 marks each. Plan the 6 or more ideas you need, write your answer on paper, then open the model answer and mark yourself against the marking points. Or print the questions and mark them with the answers sheet.
Priya looks at two samples under a microscope. Sample A is a cell scraped from the inside of her cheek. Sample B is a bacterium from yoghurt.
Compare the structure of the cheek cell with the structure of the bacterial cell.
6 marks
Show the model answer
Model answer
Both cells have a cell membrane that controls what enters and leaves, cytoplasm where chemical reactions happen, and ribosomes where proteins are made.
The cheek cell is a eukaryotic cell, so its genetic material is kept inside a nucleus. The bacterium is a prokaryotic cell and has no nucleus. Instead its DNA is a single loop that lies free in the cytoplasm, and it may also have extra small rings of DNA called plasmids, which the cheek cell does not have.
The bacterium is surrounded by a cell wall outside its membrane, but the cheek cell is an animal cell and has no cell wall. The cheek cell contains mitochondria for aerobic respiration, whereas the bacterium has no mitochondria.
The two cells are also very different in size. The bacterium is much smaller, only a few micrometres long, while the cheek cell is roughly ten times bigger or more. This is why Priya would need a higher magnification to see any detail inside the bacterium.
Marking points (credit any 6 relevant points, linked in a sensible order)
both cells have a cell membrane
both cells have cytoplasm
both cells have ribosomes
the cheek cell has a nucleus; the bacterium has no nucleus
in the bacterium the genetic material is a single loop of DNA free in the cytoplasm
the bacterium may also have small rings of DNA called plasmids; the cheek cell does not
the bacterium has a cell wall; the cheek cell has no cell wall
the cheek cell has mitochondria; the bacterium does not
the bacterium is much smaller, roughly 1 to 10 micrometres compared with roughly 10 to 100 micrometres
the cheek cell is eukaryotic and the bacterium is prokaryotic
How it is marked
5-6 marks: gives both similarities and several differences, each difference stated for both cells, including where the DNA is found in each.
3-4 marks: gives a few correct differences, but some only describe one of the cells, or similarities are missing.
1-2 marks: lists one or two structures in one cell with little or no direct comparison.
What loses marks
saying bacteria have no DNA rather than no nucleus
listing parts of one cell only without saying what the other cell has
giving the cheek cell a cell wall or chloroplasts
2
Stem cells · evaluate
A research team is looking at ways to treat a condition in which cells in the pancreas stop working. They are considering three sources of stem cells.
Source
Information
Early embryo left over from fertility treatment
Can become any type of cell. Cells come from another person, so may be rejected.
Patient's own bone marrow
Can only become a few types of cell. No rejection.
Embryo made by therapeutic cloning using the patient's own body cell
Can become any type of cell. No rejection. Process is difficult and expensive.
Evaluate the use of each source of stem cells for this treatment. Give a justified conclusion.
6 marks
Show the model answer
Model answer
Stem cells from a leftover embryo can turn into any type of cell, so they could make new pancreas cells. However, they come from a different person, so the patient's immune system may attack them and the patient would need drugs to stop rejection. Some people also think it is wrong to use embryos because they could have grown into a baby.
Bone marrow stem cells from the patient would not be rejected because they have the patient's own genes, and no embryo is destroyed. The problem is that they can only become a few types of cell, so they might not be able to form pancreas cells at all.
Therapeutic cloning makes an embryo with the patient's own genes, so the cells can become pancreas cells and will not be rejected. But it still involves destroying an embryo and it is difficult and expensive. All stem cell treatments carry a risk, for example of passing on a viral infection.
Overall I think therapeutic cloning is the best choice, because it is the only source that can make the right cells without rejection. The cost and ethical concerns are drawbacks, but the treatment would actually work.
Marking points (credit any 6 relevant points, linked in a sensible order)
embryonic stem cells can differentiate into any type of cell, so could form pancreas cells
cells from a donor embryo are not genetically identical to the patient, so the immune system may reject them
rejection means the patient may need drugs to suppress the immune system
some people object to using embryos because the embryo could have developed into a person
adult bone marrow stem cells give no rejection and no embryo is destroyed
bone marrow stem cells can only form a limited range of cells, so may not form pancreas cells
therapeutic cloning gives cells with the same genes as the patient, so no rejection
therapeutic cloning still creates and destroys an embryo, and is costly and difficult
risk with any stem cells, such as infection from contaminated cells or uncontrolled cell division
a justified conclusion weighing effectiveness against ethics and cost
How it is marked
5-6 marks: weighs a benefit and a drawback for all three sources, using the table and own knowledge, and reaches a conclusion that follows from the points made.
3-4 marks: gives benefits or drawbacks for at least two sources, or a conclusion with only limited support.
1-2 marks: copies information from the table with little evaluation and no clear conclusion.
What loses marks
giving a conclusion with no reason, or one that contradicts the points made
saying bone marrow cells can become any cell
ignoring ethical issues completely
3
Microscopy · explain
Early scientists used light microscopes to study cells. Since the 1930s, electron microscopes have also been used.
Explain how the development of the electron microscope has improved our understanding of cells.
6 marks
Show the model answer
Model answer
A light microscope uses light to form an image, but an electron microscope uses a beam of electrons. This gives the electron microscope a much higher magnification, so structures can be made to look far bigger.
More importantly, it has a much higher resolution. Resolution is the ability to tell apart two points that are very close together, so a higher resolution means much finer detail can be seen instead of a blur.
Because of this, scientists could see sub-cellular structures that are too small for a light microscope. For example, ribosomes can only be seen with an electron microscope. They could also see the inside of mitochondria and chloroplasts, including their folded internal membranes. This helped scientists work out how the structure of each organelle relates to its job, such as where respiration and photosynthesis happen.
Electron microscopes also allowed bacteria to be studied in detail and made it possible to see viruses for the first time, which helped explain how some diseases are caused.
Marking points (credit any 6 relevant points, linked in a sensible order)
a light microscope uses light; an electron microscope uses a beam of electrons
electron microscopes have a much higher magnification
electron microscopes have a much higher resolution, so two points close together can be seen separately
higher resolution means finer detail is visible
small sub-cellular structures such as ribosomes can only be seen with an electron microscope
the internal structure of mitochondria and chloroplasts can be seen
scientists could link the structure of organelles to their function
very small cells such as bacteria could be studied in detail
viruses are too small to see with a light microscope but can be seen with an electron microscope
How it is marked
5-6 marks: explains that greater magnification and resolution let much smaller structures be seen, and links this to named examples of new knowledge about cells.
3-4 marks: states that electron microscopes magnify more or show more detail, with one example, but the link to understanding is weak.
1-2 marks: makes a simple statement such as electron microscopes are more powerful.
What loses marks
saying it just makes things bigger without mentioning resolution
claiming nuclei or chloroplasts could not be seen at all with a light microscope
giving no examples of what was discovered
4
Culturing microorganisms · use the data Triple only
Higher tier
Tomasz is studying a species of bacterium in a food safety lab. He grows it in a nutrient broth at two temperatures and records its mean division time.
Temperature in °C
Mean division time in minutes
20
60
37
20
He starts each culture with 500 bacteria.
Use the data to calculate the number of bacteria in each culture after 4 hours, giving your answers in standard form. Explain what the results show and why food should be kept in a fridge.
6 marks
Show the model answer
Model answer
4 hours = 240 minutes.
At 20 °C:
number of divisions = 240 / 60 = 4
number of bacteria = 500 x 24
= 500 x 16 = 8000 = 8 x 103
At 37 °C:
number of divisions = 240 / 20 = 12
number of bacteria = 500 x 212
= 500 x 4096 = 2 048 000 = 2.048 x 106
Bacteria reproduce by binary fission, so the population doubles every time they divide. At 37 °C they divide three times as often, so after 4 hours there are 256 times as many bacteria as at 20 °C. This is because their enzymes work faster as the temperature gets closer to their optimum.
A fridge keeps food at around 4 °C or lower. At this temperature the bacteria divide very slowly, so far fewer are present when the food is eaten and there is less risk of food poisoning.
Marking points (credit any 6 relevant points, linked in a sensible order)
4 hours is 240 minutes
at 20 °C the number of divisions is 240 / 60 = 4
bacteria after 4 divisions = 500 x 24 = 8000 = 8 x 103
at 37 °C the number of divisions is 240 / 20 = 12
bacteria after 12 divisions = 500 x 212 = 2 048 000 = 2.048 x 106
bacteria reproduce by binary fission, so the number doubles each division
at the higher temperature the bacteria divide faster, so the population is about 256 times larger
the enzymes in the bacteria work faster nearer their optimum temperature
a fridge keeps food at about 4 °C or below, so division is very slow
fewer bacteria means less chance of food poisoning
How it is marked
5-6 marks: both calculations correct in standard form with working, plus an explanation of the effect of temperature linked to keeping food cold.
3-4 marks: one calculation correct, or both attempted with a slip, with some explanation of the temperature effect.
1-2 marks: correct number of divisions found or a simple statement that bacteria grow faster when warm.
What loses marks
using hours instead of minutes for the division time
multiplying by the number of divisions instead of raising 2 to that power
not giving the answer in standard form
saying cold kills the bacteria rather than slowing division
5
Osmosis · explain
In hospital, fluid given into a vein through a drip is a salt solution with the same concentration as blood plasma. It is never pure water.
Explain why pure water would damage red blood cells but does not burst plant cells in a garden after heavy rain.
6 marks
Show the model answer
Model answer
Osmosis is the net movement of water from a dilute solution to a more concentrated solution through a partially permeable membrane.
Pure water is more dilute than the inside of a red blood cell. If it were put into the blood, water would move into the red blood cells by osmosis. Red blood cells are animal cells with only a thin membrane and no cell wall, so they would keep swelling until they burst, which would stop them carrying oxygen. A drip that has the same concentration as plasma causes no net movement of water, so the cells keep their normal shape.
After heavy rain, the water around the roots is also more dilute than the cytoplasm of plant cells, so water enters these cells by osmosis too. However, plant cells have a strong cell wall made of cellulose outside the membrane. As the cell fills, it pushes against the wall, which stops it swelling any further, so it does not burst. Instead the cell becomes turgid, which helps keep the plant upright.
Marking points (credit any 6 relevant points, linked in a sensible order)
osmosis is the movement of water across a partially permeable membrane
water moves from a dilute solution to a more concentrated solution
pure water is more dilute than the cytoplasm of red blood cells
water would enter the red blood cells by osmosis
red blood cells have no cell wall, so they swell and burst
a solution with the same concentration as plasma means no net movement of water, so cells keep their shape
plant cells also take in water by osmosis when surrounded by water
the plant cell wall is strong and stops the cell from bursting
the plant cell becomes firm or turgid, which helps support the plant
How it is marked
5-6 marks: explains osmosis in terms of concentration and the membrane, applies it to both cell types and uses the cell wall to explain the difference.
3-4 marks: explains that water enters cells by osmosis and that red blood cells burst, but the plant cell explanation is weak or missing.
1-2 marks: states that water goes into cells, or that plant cells have a cell wall, with little explanation.
What loses marks
saying water moves from a low to a high water concentration
describing salt moving instead of water
saying the cell membrane rather than the cell wall stops plant cells bursting
Every question here is original and written by Robinson Tuition. Aligned to the AQA GCSE science specifications; not exam-board material and not endorsed by AQA.