Pure substances and formulations · use the data
A food lab in Bristol buys benzoic acid, a preservative, from three suppliers. Pure benzoic acid melts at 122 °C. A technician, Ewan, measures the melting range of each sample.
| Sample | Starts to melt in °C | Fully melted in °C |
|---|---|---|
| X | 122 | 122 |
| Y | 114 | 119 |
| Z | 108 | 117 |
The label on sample Y says "100% pure, nothing added".
Use the data to decide which samples are pure. Explain what the word "pure" means to a chemist and why the label on Y may be misleading.
Show the model answer
To a chemist, a pure substance is a single element or a single compound with nothing else mixed in. A pure substance melts at one sharp, fixed temperature. If there are impurities, the melting point is lowered and the substance melts over a range of temperatures.
Sample X starts and finishes melting at 122 °C, which is exactly the melting point of pure benzoic acid, so X is pure.
Sample Y starts melting at 114 °C and is fully melted at 119 °C. This is below 122 °C and over a 5 °C range, so Y is impure.
Sample Z melts from 108 °C to 117 °C. This is a 9 °C range and starts even lower, so Z is the least pure of the three. The bigger the drop and the wider the range, the more impurity is present.
The label on Y is using the everyday meaning of "pure", which people take to mean natural or with nothing added. In chemistry, pure means only one substance. The melting data show that Y contains something other than benzoic acid, so the label is misleading.
- to a chemist a pure substance contains only one element or one compound
- a pure substance melts at a sharp, fixed temperature
- impurities lower the melting point and make it melt over a range of temperatures
- sample X melts sharply at 122 °C, the value for pure benzoic acid, so X is pure
- sample Y melts over a 5 °C range below 122 °C, so Y is impure
- sample Z melts over a 9 °C range starting at 108 °C, so Z is the most impure
- the bigger the drop and the wider the range, the more impurity there is
- in everyday language pure means natural or with nothing added, which is different from the chemical meaning
- the label on Y uses the everyday meaning, but the data show it contains other substances
- melting point data can therefore be used to tell pure and impure samples apart
- 5-6 marks: gives the chemical meaning of pure, uses values to judge all three samples, ranks the impurity and explains the difference between the everyday and chemical meaning for the label.
- 3-4 marks: identifies X as pure and Y and Z as impure with some use of the data, and makes a point about the label or the meaning of pure.
- 1-2 marks: identifies the pure sample or gives a definition of pure with little use of the data.
- saying an impure sample has a higher melting point
- judging the samples without quoting the temperatures
- defining pure as natural or with no chemicals
- not explaining why the label is misleading