Aligned to AQA Combined Science 8464 and AQA GCSE Chemistry 8462
To find out how the concentration of sodium thiosulfate solution affects the rate of its reaction with dilute hydrochloric acid, by timing how long a cross takes to disappear.
14 original questions, 35 marks. Try each one, then open the model answer and mark yourself against the marking points. Or print the sheet and mark it with the answers sheet. The full method is in the revision notes at the bottom.
Equipment: sodium thiosulfate solution (40 g/dm3); dilute hydrochloric acid; distilled water; 50 cm3 measuring cylinder and 10 cm3 measuring cylinder; conical flask (100 cm3); piece of white paper with a bold black cross drawn on it; stopwatch; safety goggles.
Callum and Mei timed how long the cross took to disappear at five concentrations of sodium thiosulfate, with three trials at each.
Volume of sodium thiosulfate in cm3
Volume of water in cm3
Concentration in g/dm3
Time trial 1 in s
Time trial 2 in s
Time trial 3 in s
50
0
40
31
29
30
40
10
32
38
37
36
30
20
24
49
68
51
20
30
16
74
77
75
10
40
8
148
155
151
The questions
1
State the independent variable and the dependent variable in this investigation.
2 marks
Show the model answer
Independent: the concentration of sodium thiosulfate. Dependent: the time for the cross to disappear.
Marking points
Independent: concentration of sodium thiosulfate
Dependent: time for the cross to disappear
2
Explain why water is added so that the total volume in the flask is always 50 cm3 (before the acid).
2 marks
Show the model answer
It keeps the depth of liquid above the cross the same each time. If the volume changed, the cross would be harder or easier to see, which would change the time even if the rate stayed the same.
Marking points
Same depth of liquid / same amount of cloudiness needed to hide the cross
So only the concentration affects the time (fair test)
3
This reaction gives off sulfur dioxide. Describe the risk and how to reduce it.
2 marks
Show the model answer
Sulfur dioxide irritates the lungs and can cause an asthma attack. Keep the room well ventilated, do not breathe over the flask and dispose of the mixture straight after timing.
Marking points
Irritates lungs / triggers asthma
Ventilation / do not sniff / dispose of the mixture promptly
4
Explain why the cross disappears during the reaction.
2 marks
Show the model answer
One of the products is sulfur, which is an insoluble solid. As more sulfur forms, the mixture becomes cloudy and eventually you cannot see the cross through it.
Marking points
Solid sulfur / a precipitate forms
Mixture becomes cloudy so the cross cannot be seen
5
Identify the anomalous result in the table and say what should be done with it.
2 marks
Show the model answer
Trial 2 at 24 g/dm3 (68 s). It is much longer than the other two trials at that concentration (49 s and 51 s). It should be left out when calculating the mean.
Marking points
68 s at 24 g/dm3
Ignore it when calculating the mean (or repeat that trial)
6
Calculate the mean time for 24 g/dm3, leaving out the anomalous result.
2 marks
Show the model answer
50 s
Leave out 68 s
Mean = (49 + 51) / 2
Mean = 100 / 2 = 50 s
Marking points
(49 + 51) / 2
50 s
7
Use your answer to question 6 to calculate the rate of reaction at 24 g/dm3, using rate = 1 / time. Give the unit.
2 marks
Show the model answer
0.020 /s (s-1)
Rate = 1 / time
Rate = 1 / 50
Rate = 0.020 /s
Marking points
1 / 50 = 0.020
Unit /s or s-1
8
Calculate the mean time for 40 g/dm3 and the rate at this concentration. Give the rate to 2 significant figures. Show your working.
3 marks
Show the model answer
Mean time 30 s; rate 0.033 /s
Mean = (31 + 29 + 30) / 3
Mean = 90 / 3 = 30 s
Rate = 1 / 30 = 0.0333...
Rate = 0.033 /s (2 significant figures)
Marking points
Mean = (31 + 29 + 30) / 3 = 30 s
Rate = 1 / 30
0.033 /s
9
Describe the effect of concentration on the rate of reaction and explain it using collision theory.
3 marks
Show the model answer
As the concentration increases, the time gets shorter, so the rate increases. At a higher concentration there are more thiosulfate particles in the same volume. This means collisions between the reacting particles happen more often, so there are more successful collisions per second.
Marking points
Higher concentration, faster rate (shorter time)
More particles in the same volume
More frequent collisions / more successful collisions per second
10
Higher tier
The mean times at 16 g/dm3 and 32 g/dm3 are 75.3 s and 37.0 s. What does this suggest about the relationship between concentration and rate? Use the numbers.
2 marks
Show the model answer
Doubling the concentration from 16 to 32 g/dm3 roughly halves the time (75.3 / 37.0 = 2.0), so it doubles the rate. This suggests the rate is directly proportional to the concentration.
Marking points
Doubling concentration halves the time / doubles the rate (ratio about 2)
Rate is (directly) proportional to concentration
11
Higher tier
In a different experiment, Mei collected hydrogen from magnesium and acid and plotted volume of gas against time. She drew a tangent to the curve at 25 s. The tangent passes through (10 s, 12 cm3) and (40 s, 51 cm3). Calculate the rate of reaction at 25 s. Show your working.
3 marks
Show the model answer
1.3 cm3/s
Rate = gradient of tangent = change in volume / change in time
Change in volume = 51 - 12 = 39 cm3
Change in time = 40 - 10 = 30 s
Rate = 39 / 30
Rate = 1.3 cm3/s
Marking points
Change in volume = 51 - 12 = 39 cm3
Change in time = 40 - 10 = 30 s
1.3 cm3/s
12
Callum and Mei got slightly different times when they each judged the same flask. Suggest one way to make the end point less dependent on the person watching, and explain why it helps.
2 marks
Show the model answer
Use a light sensor and data logger placed under the flask to record when the light level falls to a set value. This removes human judgement, so the end point is the same each time and the times are more repeatable.
Marking points
Light sensor / colorimeter with data logger (or same person, same cross, same lighting)
Removes subjective judgement so results are more repeatable
13
Explain the difference between results being repeatable and results being reproducible, using this investigation.
2 marks
Show the model answer
Repeatable means Callum and Mei get similar times when they repeat the same concentration themselves with the same method. Reproducible means another group, or someone using different equipment or a different method such as a light sensor, gets similar results.
Marking points
Repeatable: same person / group, same method gets similar results
Reproducible: a different person, group or method gets similar results
14
Plan an investigation to find out how the concentration of hydrochloric acid affects the rate of its reaction with magnesium ribbon, by measuring the volume of gas produced.
6 marks
Show the model answer
Wear goggles. Set up a conical flask with a bung and delivery tube leading to an upturned measuring cylinder full of water in a trough, or to a gas syringe. Measure 50 cm3 of 0.5 mol/dm3 hydrochloric acid into the flask. Cut a 3 cm length of magnesium ribbon, drop it in, put the bung in quickly and start a stopwatch. Record the volume of hydrogen every 10 seconds until no more gas is made. Repeat with 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0 mol/dm3 acid. Keep the volume of acid, the length of magnesium and the temperature the same each time. Repeat each concentration and plot volume of gas against time for each one. Work out the mean rate over the first 30 seconds, or compare the gradients at the start, to see how concentration affects rate. Keep flames away because hydrogen is flammable.
Marking points (any 6, with the method in a logical order)
Conical flask, bung and delivery tube to gas syringe or upturned measuring cylinder
Fixed volume of acid measured with a measuring cylinder
Same length / mass of magnesium ribbon each time
Start the stopwatch when magnesium is added and bung inserted
Record gas volume at regular time intervals
At least four concentrations of acid
Control: volume of acid, mass of magnesium, temperature
Plot volume against time / calculate rate as volume / time
Repeat each concentration; safety such as goggles, no flames near hydrogen
How it is marked
5-6 marks: a clear, workable plan with gas collection apparatus, timed volume readings, a range of concentrations, control variables, repeats and a way of working out the rate.
3-4 marks: a mostly workable plan, but some detail missing, such as how gas is collected or what is kept the same.
1-2 marks: some relevant ideas, such as adding magnesium to acid and timing, but not a coherent method.
Revision notes: the method in full
Aim: To find out how the concentration of sodium thiosulfate solution affects the rate of its reaction with dilute hydrochloric acid, by timing how long a cross takes to disappear.
Equipment
sodium thiosulfate solution (40 g/dm3)
dilute hydrochloric acid
distilled water
50 cm3 measuring cylinder and 10 cm3 measuring cylinder
conical flask (100 cm3)
piece of white paper with a bold black cross drawn on it
stopwatch
safety goggles
Method
Draw a bold black cross on a sheet of white paper and put the conical flask on top of it.
Measure 50 cm3 of sodium thiosulfate solution into the flask.
Measure 10 cm3 of dilute hydrochloric acid in a separate small measuring cylinder.
Add the acid to the flask, swirl once and start the stopwatch at the same moment.
Look down through the flask from above. Stop the stopwatch when you can no longer see the cross.
Record the time, then pour the mixture away as directed by your teacher and rinse the flask.
Repeat with diluted thiosulfate: 40 cm3 thiosulfate + 10 cm3 water, then 30 + 20, 20 + 30 and 10 + 40, so the total volume is always 50 cm3.
Do each concentration three times and find the mean time, then work out the rate as 1 / mean time.
Variables
Independent: The concentration of the sodium thiosulfate solution (changed by diluting with water).
Dependent: The time taken for the cross to disappear, measured with a stopwatch, used to calculate rate = 1 / time.
Control: Total volume of thiosulfate solution plus water (50 cm3); Volume and concentration of hydrochloric acid (10 cm3); Temperature of the solutions; The same cross, flask and person judging when the cross disappears
Hazards
Hazard
What could happen
How to reduce the risk
Sulfur dioxide gas given off
Irritates the lungs; can trigger an asthma attack
Work in a well-ventilated room, do not sniff the flask, and pour the mixture into a fume cupboard sink or sodium carbonate bath as soon as timing ends
Dilute hydrochloric acid
Irritates the eyes
Wear safety goggles
Key points
Rate = 1 / time: a shorter time means a faster rate.
Keep the total volume the same, so the depth of liquid over the cross is always the same.
Higher concentration means more particles in the same volume, so more frequent collisions.
The cross disappears because the reaction makes solid sulfur, which turns the mixture cloudy.
Judging when the cross vanishes is subjective: use the same person and the same cross each time.
Rate from a tangent on a gas volume graph is Higher tier: gradient = change in y / change in x.
Every question and data set here is original and written by Robinson Tuition. Aligned to AQA Combined Science 8464 and AQA GCSE Chemistry 8462; this is not an exam-board paper and is not endorsed by AQA.