Aligned to AQA GCSE Biology 8461 only (not Combined Science)
To find out how temperature affects the rate at which lipase breaks down the fat in milk, by timing a pH change.
14 original questions, 35 marks. Try each one, then open the model answer and mark yourself against the marking points. Or print the sheet and mark it with the answers sheet. The full method is in the revision notes at the bottom.
Equipment: Full-fat milk; Lipase solution; Sodium carbonate solution (makes the milk alkaline); Phenolphthalein indicator; Test tubes and a rack; Measuring cylinders or syringes; Water baths set at different temperatures; Thermometer; Stopwatch; Glass stirring rod; White tile behind the tubes.
Mohammed and Grace timed how long it took the pink colour to disappear at five temperatures, doing three repeats at each.
Temperature in °C
Time 1 in s
Time 2 in s
Time 3 in s
Mean time in s
15
412
398
405
405
25
236
251
243
243
35
128
134
131
131
45
102
168
98
?
55
290
305
298
298
The questions
1
Name the independent variable and the dependent variable in Mohammed and Grace's investigation.
2 marks
Show the model answer
The independent variable is the temperature. The dependent variable is the time taken for the pink colour to disappear (which shows the rate of decay).
Marking points
Independent: temperature
Dependent: time for the colour to disappear (or rate of decay)
2
Give one control variable and explain why it must be kept the same.
2 marks
Show the model answer
The volume of lipase solution. More enzyme would break down the fat faster, so the time would change even at the same temperature.
Marking points
A sensible control, such as volume or concentration of lipase, volume or type of milk, or volume of sodium carbonate
A matching reason, such as it would change the rate of reaction for another reason
3
Explain why the milk mixture and the lipase are put in the water bath separately for 5 minutes before they are mixed.
2 marks
Show the model answer
So both reach the temperature of the water bath before the reaction starts. If they were mixed straight away, the reaction would begin at room temperature and the time would not match the temperature being tested.
Marking points
So both are at the bath temperature before mixing
So the reaction happens at the stated temperature from the start (otherwise the time is wrong)
4
Describe one hazard in this practical and how to reduce the risk.
2 marks
Show the model answer
Phenolphthalein is dissolved in ethanol, which is flammable and can irritate the eyes. Wear safety glasses and keep it away from any Bunsen burner flames.
Marking points
A hazard, such as phenolphthalein or ethanol, lipase allergy or hot water
A matching precaution, such as eye protection, no flames, avoid skin contact or use a tube holder
5
Explain why the pink colour disappears during the reaction.
2 marks
Show the model answer
Lipase breaks down the fat in milk into fatty acids and glycerol. The fatty acids lower the pH, so the mixture is no longer alkaline and the phenolphthalein turns colourless.
Marking points
Lipase breaks fat (lipid) into fatty acids (and glycerol)
Fatty acids lower the pH, so the indicator goes colourless
6
Identify the anomalous result. Explain how you know.
2 marks
Show the model answer
Time 2 at 45 °C, 168 s, is anomalous. The other two times at 45 °C were 102 s and 98 s, so 168 s is much longer and does not fit.
Marking points
168 s at 45 °C
It is far from the other repeats at that temperature (102 s and 98 s)
7
Calculate the mean time at 45 °C. Do not include the anomalous result.
2 marks
Show the model answer
(102 + 98) / 2 = 100 s
Leave out 168
102 + 98 = 200
200 / 2 = 100
Mean time = 100 s
Marking points
Adds 102 and 98 and divides by 2
100 s
8
Calculate the rate of reaction at 35 °C and at 45 °C using rate = 1000 / mean time.
Give your answers to 2 significant figures. Show your working.
3 marks
Show the model answer
35 °C: 1000 / 131 = 7.6 s-1
45 °C: 1000 / 100 = 10 s-1
Rate = 1000 / mean time
35 °C: rate = 1000 / 131 = 7.633...
Rate at 35 °C = 7.6 s-1
45 °C: rate = 1000 / 100 = 10
Rate at 45 °C = 10 s-1
Marking points
Uses rate = 1000 / mean time
35 °C: 7.6 s-1
45 °C: 10 s-1 (using the mean from the previous question)
9
Describe how the rate of decay changes with temperature from 15 °C to 55 °C.
2 marks
Show the model answer
The rate increases as the temperature rises from 15 °C to 45 °C, as the time drops from 405 s to 100 s. The rate then falls between 45 °C and 55 °C, where the time goes up to 298 s.
Marking points
Rate increases from 15 °C up to about 45 °C (times get shorter)
Rate decreases above 45 °C (time increases to 298 s at 55 °C)
10
Explain why the rate at 55 °C is lower than at 45 °C.
3 marks
Show the model answer
At 55 °C the high temperature breaks some of the bonds holding the lipase molecule in shape, so the enzyme denatures. The shape of its active site changes and fat molecules no longer fit into it. Fewer enzyme-substrate complexes form, so fat is broken down more slowly.
Marking points
Enzyme (lipase) is denatured at high temperature
The active site changes shape
So the substrate (fat) no longer fits and fewer enzyme-substrate complexes form
11
Higher tier
How many times faster is the reaction at 35 °C than at 15 °C? Give your answer to 2 significant figures.
2 marks
Show the model answer
Rate is inversely proportional to time, so 405 / 131 = 3.1 times faster.
Rate at 35 °C / rate at 15 °C = time at 15 °C / time at 35 °C
= 405 / 131
= 3.09...
= 3.1 times faster
Marking points
Divides the time at 15 °C by the time at 35 °C (or compares the two rates)
3.1 times faster
12
Grace repeated the test at 35 °C using a pH probe instead of the indicator. The pH fell from 9.5 to 7.7 in 3 minutes.
Calculate the rate of pH change in pH units per minute.
2 marks
Show the model answer
Change in pH = 9.5 - 7.7 = 1.8. Rate = 1.8 / 3 = 0.6 pH units per minute
Change in pH = 9.5 - 7.7 = 1.8
Rate = change in pH / time
= 1.8 / 3
= 0.6 pH units per minute
Marking points
Change in pH = 1.8
0.6 pH units per minute
13
Mohammed and Grace found it hard to decide exactly when the pink colour had gone.
Is this a source of random error or systematic error? Explain your answer.
Suggest an improvement and explain why it helps.
3 marks
Show the model answer
a) Random error, because sometimes they would stop the clock a little early and sometimes a little late, so the times scatter around the true value.
b) Use a pH probe and data logger to record when the pH falls to the same value each time. This removes the need to judge the colour by eye, so the end point is measured the same way every time and the results are more accurate.
Marking points
Random error
Because the judgement varies from one test to the next (readings scatter either side)
Improvement with reason, such as a pH probe or data logger (or a colour standard to compare with) so the end point is not judged by eye
14
Plan an investigation to find out how the concentration of lipase affects the rate of decay of the fat in milk.
6 marks
Show the model answer
Make lipase solutions of 1%, 2%, 3%, 4% and 5% by diluting a stock solution with distilled water. Put 5 cm3 of full-fat milk, 7 cm3 of sodium carbonate solution and 5 drops of phenolphthalein into a test tube so it turns pink. Put 1 cm3 of the 1% lipase in a separate tube. Stand both tubes in a water bath at 35 °C for 5 minutes, checking the temperature with a thermometer. Pour the lipase into the milk, stir and start a stopwatch. Stop the stopwatch when the pink colour disappears, looking against a white tile. Repeat three times for each concentration, using fresh milk each time and the same volumes, and calculate the mean time, leaving out any anomalous results. Calculate the rate as 1000 / mean time and plot a graph of rate against lipase concentration. Wear eye protection and avoid skin contact with the lipase.
Marking points (any 6, with the method in a logical order)
Uses a range of at least five lipase concentrations
Mixes milk, sodium carbonate and phenolphthalein so the mixture is pink
Same volume of milk, sodium carbonate, indicator and lipase each time
Temperature kept constant with a water bath
Lets the solutions reach the bath temperature before mixing
Times how long until the pink colour disappears
Repeats for each concentration and calculates a mean
Calculates rate as 1000 / time and plots against concentration
Sensible safety, such as eye protection
How it is marked
5-6 marks: a clear, ordered plan that changes lipase concentration over a sensible range, keeps temperature and volumes constant, times the colour change, repeats, and turns times into rates.
3-4 marks: a workable plan with the main steps, but some controls, the end point or repeats are missing or unclear.
1-2 marks: a few relevant ideas, such as adding different amounts of lipase to milk and timing something, with little detail or control.
Revision notes: the method in full
Aim: To find out how temperature affects the rate at which lipase breaks down the fat in milk, by timing a pH change.
Equipment
Full-fat milk
Lipase solution
Sodium carbonate solution (makes the milk alkaline)
Phenolphthalein indicator
Test tubes and a rack
Measuring cylinders or syringes
Water baths set at different temperatures
Thermometer
Stopwatch
Glass stirring rod
White tile behind the tubes
Method
Measure 5 drops of phenolphthalein into a test tube.
Add 5 cm3 of milk and 7 cm3 of sodium carbonate solution; the mixture turns pink because it is alkaline.
Put 1 cm3 of lipase solution into a separate test tube.
Stand both tubes in a water bath at 15 °C and leave them for 5 minutes so they reach the temperature; check with a thermometer.
Pour the lipase into the milk mixture, stir and start the stopwatch at once.
Stop the stopwatch when the pink colour disappears, viewing the tube against a white tile.
Repeat twice more at this temperature and calculate a mean time.
Repeat the whole method at 25 °C, 35 °C, 45 °C and 55 °C.
Calculate the rate for each temperature using rate = 1000 / mean time.
Variables
Independent: Temperature of the water bath.
Dependent: Rate of decay, found from the time taken for the pink colour to disappear (rate = 1000 / time).
Control: Volume and type of milk (same fat content); Volume and concentration of lipase; Volume of sodium carbonate solution; Number of drops of phenolphthalein; Same end point judged against a white tile
Hazards
Hazard
What could happen
How to reduce the risk
Phenolphthalein (made up in ethanol)
Flammable and irritating to the eyes
Wear eye protection and keep it away from naked flames
Lipase enzyme
Can cause an allergic reaction if it touches the skin or is breathed in
Avoid skin contact, wash off any spills straight away, and wear eye protection
Hot water in the 55 °C bath
Scalds
Handle tubes with a test tube holder and do not overfill the bath
Key points
Lipase breaks fat down into fatty acids and glycerol; the fatty acids lower the pH, so the indicator changes colour.
Phenolphthalein is pink in alkali and colourless when the pH falls below about 8.3.
Rate = 1000 / time: the shorter the time, the faster the rate.
Warm both the milk mixture and the lipase to the bath temperature before mixing.
Above the optimum temperature the enzyme denatures: its active site changes shape, so the rate falls.
The end point is a judgement, so a pH probe or data logger gives a more accurate result than watching the colour.
Every question and data set here is original and written by Robinson Tuition. Aligned to AQA GCSE Biology 8461 only (not Combined Science); this is not an exam-board paper and is not endorsed by AQA.