Exothermic and endothermic reactions · compare
A pharmacy in Bristol sells two kinds of single-use pack. A hand warmer gets hot when a seal is broken. An instant cold pack for sports injuries gets cold when it is squeezed.
Compare the reactions in the two packs. Include energy transfers, temperature changes and what a reaction profile would show for each.
Show the model answer
The hand warmer uses an exothermic reaction, whereas the cold pack uses an endothermic reaction.
In the exothermic reaction, energy is transferred from the chemicals to the surroundings, so the temperature of the surroundings, including your hands, rises. In the endothermic reaction, energy is taken in from the surroundings, so the temperature of the surroundings falls and the injury is cooled.
On a reaction profile for the hand warmer, the products would be at a lower energy level than the reactants, because energy has been given out. For the cold pack, the products would be at a higher energy level than the reactants, because energy has been taken in. Both profiles would show a hump at the start, the activation energy, which is the minimum energy the particles need to react.
In terms of bonds, in the exothermic reaction more energy is released making new bonds than is needed to break the old bonds. In the endothermic reaction, more energy is needed to break bonds than is released when new bonds form.
Both packs can only be used once, because once the reactants are used up the reaction stops.
- The hand warmer uses an exothermic reaction; the cold pack uses an endothermic reaction
- Exothermic: energy is transferred to the surroundings, so the temperature of the surroundings rises
- Endothermic: energy is taken in from the surroundings, so the temperature of the surroundings falls
- Exothermic profile: products are at a lower energy level than reactants
- Endothermic profile: products are at a higher energy level than reactants
- Both profiles show an activation energy hump, the minimum energy needed for particles to react
- Exothermic: more energy released making new bonds than taken in breaking bonds
- Endothermic: more energy taken in breaking bonds than released making bonds
- Both packs are single use because the reactants are used up; other examples: combustion is exothermic, thermal decomposition is endothermic
- 5-6 marks: compares both reactions point by point for energy transfer, temperature change and reaction profile, and links the difference to bond breaking and making.
- 3-4 marks: correctly names each reaction type and compares energy transfer or temperature, with a partly correct description of the profiles.
- 1-2 marks: states that one gets hot and one gets cold, or names one reaction type correctly.
- Saying the cold pack 'gives out cold' instead of taking in energy
- Drawing or describing the endothermic profile with products lower than reactants
- Saying making bonds takes in energy