Collision theory: concentration and surface area · explain
Limescale is calcium carbonate. It builds up inside kettles in hard-water areas. Descaler is an acid solution that reacts with limescale, giving off bubbles of carbon dioxide.
Ruby notices two things:
- a more concentrated descaler removes the limescale faster
- thin flakes of limescale disappear faster than one thick lump of the same mass
Use collision theory to explain both observations.
Show the model answer
For the acid to react with the limescale, acid particles must collide with calcium carbonate particles with at least the activation energy. The rate of reaction depends on how often these successful collisions happen.
A more concentrated descaler contains more acid particles in the same volume of solution. This means the acid particles collide with the surface of the limescale more frequently, so there are more successful collisions per second and the limescale is removed faster.
Thin flakes of limescale have a much larger surface area than one thick lump of the same mass, so they have a larger surface area to volume ratio. More of the calcium carbonate particles are exposed to the acid at the same time. This means collisions between acid particles and calcium carbonate particles happen more frequently, so the flakes react faster.
In both cases the particles are not moving any faster and do not have more energy. The rate increases only because collisions happen more often.
- Particles must collide with enough energy (the activation energy) to react
- Rate depends on the frequency of successful collisions
- A more concentrated acid has more acid particles in the same volume
- So acid particles collide with the limescale more often, increasing the rate
- Flakes of the same mass have a larger surface area than one lump (larger surface area to volume ratio)
- More calcium carbonate particles are exposed to the acid
- So collisions happen more frequently and the reaction is faster
- Neither change makes particles move faster or gives them more energy
- Both increase the number of collisions per second, not the energy of each collision
- 5-6 marks: explains both observations by more frequent collisions, with the reason for each (more particles per volume, more exposed particles) and links to rate.
- 3-4 marks: explains one observation fully and the other partly, or says 'more collisions' without saying more frequent.
- 1-2 marks: describes the observations or says the particles collide more, with little explanation.
- Saying 'more collisions' instead of more frequent collisions
- Saying higher concentration gives the particles more energy
- Saying the flakes have a smaller surface area because they are smaller pieces