Robinson Tuition
Chemistry Paper 2 · Using resources · free required practical sheet

Analysing and purifying water

Aligned to AQA Combined Science 8464 and AQA GCSE Chemistry 8462

To measure the pH and the mass of dissolved solids in water samples from different sources, and to purify salty water by distillation.

14 original questions, 35 marks. Try each one, then open the model answer and mark yourself against the marking points. Or print the sheet and mark it with the answers sheet. The full method is in the revision notes at the bottom.

Practical sheet PDFAnswers and revision notes PDF

The results

Equipment: water samples (for example tap water, sea water, pond water, rainwater); universal indicator paper and colour chart, or a pH meter; evaporating basins; balance reading to 0.001 g; 50 cm3 measuring cylinder; Bunsen burner, tripod, gauze and heatproof mat; conical flask with bung and delivery tube; test tube in a beaker of ice-cold water to collect the distillate; thermometer; safety goggles.

Jamal and Sofia evaporated 50.0 cm3 of five water samples and weighed the basins before and after. They also tested each sample with a pH meter.

SamplepHMass of empty basin in gMass of basin and solid after evaporating in gMass of dissolved solids in g
Tap water7.448.31248.3290.017
Sea water8.147.90549.660?
Pond water6.849.12049.1410.021
Rainwater5.648.55648.5580.002
Distilled water7.048.77448.7740.000

The questions

1

State the independent variable and one dependent variable in Jamal and Sofia's investigation.

2 marks
Show the model answer

Independent: the source of the water. Dependent: the mass of dissolved solids (or the pH).

Marking points
  • Independent: the source / type of water sample
  • Dependent: mass of dissolved solids or pH
2

Explain why the same volume of each water sample must be evaporated.

2 marks
Show the model answer

A larger volume of the same water would contain more dissolved solid. Using 50.0 cm3 each time means the masses can be compared fairly.

Marking points
  • More water would leave more solid
  • So the masses can be compared fairly
3

Describe how to measure the pH of a water sample with universal indicator paper.

2 marks
Show the model answer

Dip a clean glass rod in the sample and touch it on a piece of universal indicator paper. Match the colour with the pH chart and record the pH.

Marking points
  • Put a drop of sample on the indicator paper (glass rod)
  • Compare the colour with the colour chart to read the pH
4

During distillation the delivery tube becomes blocked. Explain the hazard and how to prevent it.

2 marks
Show the model answer

Steam cannot escape, so the pressure builds up in the flask. The bung could shoot out or the glass could break, spraying hot water. Check the tube is clear before heating and never heat a completely sealed system.

Marking points
  • Pressure builds up so the bung shoots out / glass breaks / hot water sprays
  • Check tube is clear / never heat a sealed system / wear goggles
5

Calculate the mass of dissolved solids in the sea water sample.

1 mark
Show the model answer

1.755 g

Mass of solids = mass after - mass of empty basin
Mass of solids = 49.660 - 47.905 = 1.755 g
Marking points
  • 1.755 g
6

Calculate the concentration of dissolved solids in the sea water in g/dm3. Use your answer to question 5. Give your answer to 3 significant figures. Show your working.

3 marks
Show the model answer

35.1 g/dm3

Volume = 50.0 / 1000 = 0.0500 dm3
Concentration = mass / volume
Concentration = 1.755 / 0.0500 = 35.1
Concentration = 35.1 g/dm3
Marking points
  • Volume = 50.0 / 1000 = 0.0500 dm3
  • 1.755 / 0.0500
  • 35.1 g/dm3
7

Calculate the concentration of dissolved solids in the tap water in g/dm3.

2 marks
Show the model answer

0.34 g/dm3

Volume = 50.0 / 1000 = 0.0500 dm3
Concentration = 0.017 / 0.0500
Concentration = 0.34 g/dm3
Marking points
  • 0.017 / 0.0500
  • 0.34 g/dm3
8

Which sample is pure water? Give two pieces of evidence from the table.

2 marks
Show the model answer

The distilled water. It has a pH of 7.0, and it left no solid behind (0.000 g) when it was evaporated.

Marking points
  • pH is 7.0 (neutral)
  • No dissolved solid left after evaporation
9

Tap water is potable but is not pure. Use the results to explain what this means.

2 marks
Show the model answer

Potable means it is safe to drink. The tap water left 0.017 g of solid, so it still has some dissolved substances in it, which means it is not pure in the chemical sense.

Marking points
  • Potable = safe to drink
  • It contains dissolved solids (0.017 g), so it is not pure
10

Explain how distillation separates pure water from sea water, and why the collecting test tube stands in ice-cold water.

3 marks
Show the model answer

When the sea water is heated, the water boils and turns into steam, but the dissolved salts do not evaporate and stay in the flask. The steam is cooled in the cold test tube and condenses back into liquid water, which is pure. The ice-cold water keeps the test tube cold so that as much steam as possible condenses instead of escaping.

Marking points
  • Water evaporates / boils but the salts stay behind
  • Steam is cooled and condenses into pure water
  • Ice-cold water keeps the tube cold so more steam condenses
11

A desalination plant takes in sea water with the same concentration as Jamal and Sofia's sample. Use your answer to question 6 to calculate the mass of dissolved solids removed from 2.5 dm3 of this sea water. Give your answer to 2 significant figures.

2 marks
Show the model answer

88 g

Mass = concentration x volume
Mass = 35.1 x 2.5 = 87.75
Mass = 88 g (2 significant figures)
Marking points
  • Mass = concentration x volume = 35.1 x 2.5
  • 88 g
12

Higher tier

The balance reads to 0.001 g. Sofia says the result for rainwater (0.002 g) has a much larger uncertainty than the result for sea water (1.755 g). Explain why she is right, and suggest one improvement.

3 marks
Show the model answer

The resolution of the balance is 0.001 g, which is half of the 0.002 g measured for rainwater, so the uncertainty is a huge fraction of the result. For sea water, 0.001 g is a tiny fraction of 1.755 g. To improve this, evaporate a much larger volume of rainwater, such as 500 cm3, so the mass of solid is larger compared with the resolution.

Marking points
  • The uncertainty / resolution (0.001 g) is a large fraction of 0.002 g
  • But a very small fraction of 1.755 g
  • Evaporate a larger volume of rainwater so the mass of solid is bigger
13

Jamal did not let the basin cool before weighing it after evaporation. Suggest how this could affect his result, explain why weighing until the mass stays the same is a better method, and say whether any remaining water causes a random or a systematic error.

3 marks
Show the model answer

A hot basin can make the balance reading unsteady or inaccurate, and some water may still be left in the solid, so the mass of solid could be wrong. Cooling, weighing, warming again and reweighing until two readings match shows that all the water has gone. Water left in the solid always makes the mass too high, so it is a systematic error.

Marking points
  • Hot basin / remaining water gives an inaccurate mass
  • Heating to constant mass shows all the water has been removed
  • Remaining water always makes the mass too high: systematic error
14

A pupil has collected a sample of distilled water from her distillation of sea water. Plan how she could test whether the distilled water is pure, and say what results she would expect if it is.

6 marks
Show the model answer

First, test the pH with a calibrated pH meter or universal indicator paper. Pure water should have a pH of 7. Next, weigh a clean, dry evaporating basin on a balance reading to 0.001 g, add a measured 50.0 cm3 of the distilled water and heat it gently until it has all evaporated. Let it cool and weigh again; pure water leaves no solid, so the mass should not change. She could also find the boiling point: heat some of the water in a boiling tube with anti-bumping granules and a thermometer in the liquid, and record the steady temperature when it boils. Pure water boils at 100 °C; dissolved salt would raise the boiling point. Comparing her results with the original sea water, which has a higher pH, leaves a lot of solid and boils above 100 °C, would show the distillation has worked. She should wear goggles and take care with hot glassware.

Marking points (any 6, with the method in a logical order)
  • Test pH with indicator paper or pH meter
  • Pure water has pH 7
  • Evaporate a measured volume in a weighed basin
  • Reweigh: no mass of solid left if pure
  • Measure boiling point with a thermometer
  • Pure water boils at 100 °C
  • Compare with the original sea water
  • Safety: goggles, care with hot apparatus, gentle heating
How it is marked
  • 5-6 marks: at least two suitable tests described clearly, each with the expected result for pure water, organised so that another person could follow the plan.
  • 3-4 marks: one test described well with its result, or two tests with little detail or missing expected results.
  • 1-2 marks: a relevant idea such as testing the pH or boiling it, with no clear method or expected result.

Revision notes: the method in full

Aim: To measure the pH and the mass of dissolved solids in water samples from different sources, and to purify salty water by distillation.

Equipment

  • water samples (for example tap water, sea water, pond water, rainwater)
  • universal indicator paper and colour chart, or a pH meter
  • evaporating basins
  • balance reading to 0.001 g
  • 50 cm3 measuring cylinder
  • Bunsen burner, tripod, gauze and heatproof mat
  • conical flask with bung and delivery tube
  • test tube in a beaker of ice-cold water to collect the distillate
  • thermometer
  • safety goggles

Method

  1. Test the pH of each water sample: dip a glass rod in the sample, touch it on universal indicator paper and compare the colour with the chart, or use a calibrated pH meter.
  2. Weigh a clean, dry evaporating basin and record its mass.
  3. Measure 50.0 cm3 of the water sample with a measuring cylinder and pour it into the basin.
  4. Heat the basin gently over a Bunsen burner or on a water bath until all the water has evaporated.
  5. Let the basin cool, then weigh it again. The increase in mass is the mass of dissolved solids.
  6. Repeat for each water sample, using a clean basin each time.
  7. To purify salty water, put it in a conical flask fitted with a bung and delivery tube that leads into a test tube standing in ice-cold water.
  8. Heat the salty water gently until it boils. The steam travels along the tube and condenses in the cold test tube.
  9. Test the distilled water collected: its pH should be about 7, and evaporating it should leave no solid behind.

Variables

  • Independent: The source of the water sample.
  • Dependent: The pH (indicator paper or pH meter) and the mass of dissolved solids left after evaporation (measured on a balance).
  • Control: Volume of water evaporated (50.0 cm3); Same balance for every weighing; Basins clean and dry before weighing; Same method of testing pH for each sample

Hazards

HazardWhat could happenHow to reduce the risk
Hot evaporating basin and boiling liquidBurns, or hot water spitting outHeat gently, wear goggles and let the basin cool before moving it, or use tongs
Pressure building up in the flask during distillationThe bung could shoot out, or hot liquid could suck backMake sure the delivery tube is not blocked and does not dip below the liquid in the collecting tube; add anti-bumping granules
Pond water sampleMay contain harmful microorganismsWear gloves if needed, never drink any sample, and wash hands afterwards

Key points

  • Potable water is safe to drink but is not pure: it still contains small amounts of dissolved substances.
  • Pure water has a pH of 7, boils at exactly 100 °C and leaves no solid when evaporated.
  • Mass of dissolved solids = mass of basin after evaporating - mass of empty basin.
  • Distillation works because water boils and condenses, while dissolved salts stay behind in the flask.
  • Concentration in g/dm3 = mass in g / volume in dm3; divide cm3 by 1000.
  • Use a balance with good resolution: the masses of solid from fresh water are very small.

Every question and data set here is original and written by Robinson Tuition. Aligned to AQA Combined Science 8464 and AQA GCSE Chemistry 8462; this is not an exam-board paper and is not endorsed by AQA.