Robinson Tuition
Chemistry Paper 2 · Chemical analysis · free required practical sheet

Paper chromatography

Aligned to AQA Combined Science 8464 and AQA GCSE Chemistry 8462

To separate the coloured substances in inks or food colourings by paper chromatography, and to identify them by calculating Rf values.

14 original questions, 35 marks. Try each one, then open the model answer and mark yourself against the marking points. Or print the sheet and mark it with the answers sheet. The full method is in the revision notes at the bottom.

Practical sheet PDFAnswers and revision notes PDF

The results

Equipment: chromatography paper; pencil and ruler; capillary tubes or fine glass rods; food colouring samples, known and unknown; beaker (250 cm3); water as the solvent; glass rod or split cork to hang the paper; lid or watch glass to cover the beaker; safety goggles.

Ella ran a chromatogram of three known food colourings, A, B and C, and an unknown colouring X from a sweet. The solvent moved 8.4 cm from the start line. She measured each spot.

SampleSpotDistance moved by spot in cmDistance moved by solvent in cmRf value
A (red)12.18.40.25
B (yellow)16.38.4?
C (blue)14.48.4?
X12.18.4?
X24.48.4?

The questions

1

Explain why the start line is drawn in pencil and not in ink.

2 marks
Show the model answer

Pencil is graphite, which does not dissolve in the solvent, so it stays where it is. Ink would dissolve and move up the paper, mixing with the spots.

Marking points
  • Pencil (graphite) does not dissolve / move
  • Ink would dissolve and spread, confusing the results
2

Explain why the water level in the beaker must be below the start line.

2 marks
Show the model answer

If the spots were under the water, the colourings would dissolve into the water in the beaker instead of moving up the paper, so they would not separate.

Marking points
  • Spots would dissolve into the solvent in the beaker
  • So they would not travel up the paper / no separation
3

Give two variables Ella should keep the same if she wants to compare her Rf values with another class's results.

2 marks
Show the model answer

The solvent used (water) and the type of chromatography paper.

Marking points
  • Same solvent
  • Same type of paper (or same temperature)
4

Another pupil wants to use ethanol as the solvent. Give the hazard and a way to reduce the risk.

2 marks
Show the model answer

Ethanol is flammable and its vapour could catch fire. Keep all flames away and put a lid on the beaker to keep the vapour in.

Marking points
  • Ethanol is flammable
  • No naked flames nearby / lid on / good ventilation
5

Calculate the Rf value of the spot from B.

2 marks
Show the model answer

0.75

Rf = distance moved by spot / distance moved by solvent
Rf = 6.3 / 8.4
Rf = 0.75
Marking points
  • 6.3 / 8.4
  • 0.75
6

Calculate the Rf value of the spot from C. Give your answer to 2 significant figures.

2 marks
Show the model answer

0.52

Rf = 4.4 / 8.4
Rf = 0.5238...
Rf = 0.52 (2 significant figures)
Marking points
  • 4.4 / 8.4
  • 0.52
7

Use the results to say which colourings are in X. Explain your answer.

3 marks
Show the model answer

X contains A and C. X has two spots, so it is a mixture. One spot has an Rf of 0.25, the same as A, and the other has an Rf of 0.52, the same as C. It does not contain B, because there is no spot at 0.75.

Marking points
  • X is a mixture (two spots)
  • Contains A and C
  • Rf values match (0.25 and 0.52); no spot matches B
8

Is food colouring B a pure substance? Explain your answer.

2 marks
Show the model answer

It is probably pure, because it only produced one spot. A mixture would usually have separated into two or more spots.

Marking points
  • Probably pure
  • Only one spot
9

Ella tests a green colouring in the same way. The solvent moves 8.4 cm again. One of its spots has an Rf value of 0.62. Calculate how far that spot moved from the start line. Give your answer to 2 significant figures. Show your working.

3 marks
Show the model answer

5.2 cm

Rf = distance moved by spot / distance moved by solvent
Distance moved by spot = Rf x distance moved by solvent
Distance moved by spot = 0.62 x 8.4
Distance moved by spot = 5.208
Distance moved by spot = 5.2 cm (2 significant figures)
Marking points
  • Rearranges: distance moved by spot = Rf x distance moved by solvent
  • 0.62 x 8.4 = 5.208
  • 5.2 cm
10

Higher tier

Explain, in terms of the mobile phase and the stationary phase, why colouring B travels further up the paper than colouring A.

3 marks
Show the model answer

The mobile phase is the water moving up the paper and the stationary phase is the paper. Each substance spends some time dissolved in the water and some time stuck to the paper. B is more soluble in the water and less attracted to the paper than A, so it spends more time in the mobile phase and travels further.

Marking points
  • Mobile phase = solvent (water); stationary phase = paper
  • Substances are distributed between the two phases
  • B is more attracted to / soluble in the mobile phase (less to the paper), so it moves further
11

Higher tier

A pupil in another school found an Rf of 0.41 for colouring C using ethanol as the solvent. Explain why this does not mean that either result is wrong.

2 marks
Show the model answer

Rf values depend on the solvent, because the solubility of the colouring is different in ethanol than in water. Rf values can only be compared when the same solvent and paper are used.

Marking points
  • Rf depends on the solvent (solubility differs)
  • Only compare Rf values using the same solvent / conditions
12

Ella's spots were large and smeared, which made it hard to measure to the centre. Suggest how she could improve this and explain why it helps.

2 marks
Show the model answer

Use a fine capillary tube to put on a very small spot, let it dry and add more on top. Small, concentrated spots separate into neat spots that are easier to measure accurately.

Marking points
  • Small spots applied with a fine capillary, dried between applications
  • Spots stay small and separate, so distances are measured more accurately
13

Ella took the paper out of the beaker but forgot to mark the solvent front straight away. By the time she marked it, the water had spread a little further up the damp paper, but the spots had not moved. Explain the effect on her Rf values.

2 marks
Show the model answer

The solvent distance she measured would be too large, so dividing by it gives Rf values that are too small.

Marking points
  • Solvent distance too large (or front position wrong)
  • So Rf values are too low
14

Plan an investigation, using paper chromatography, to find out whether the black ink in a pen found at a crime scene matches the ink in one of three suspects' pens.

6 marks
Show the model answer

Draw a pencil line 2 cm from the bottom of a sheet of chromatography paper and mark four crosses along it. Put a small dot of ink from the crime-scene pen on one cross and dots from each suspect's pen on the others, labelling each in pencil. Pour a suitable solvent, such as water or ethanol, into a beaker to a depth below the line. Hang the paper so it just dips into the solvent and put a lid on. When the solvent is near the top, remove the paper and mark the solvent front in pencil. Let it dry. Compare the spots: the matching pen will give the same number of spots, of the same colours, at the same heights. To be sure, measure the distances and calculate Rf = distance moved by spot / distance moved by solvent for each spot and check they match. If no spots move in water, repeat with a different solvent. Keep flames away if using ethanol.

Marking points (any 6, with the method in a logical order)
  • Pencil start line above solvent level
  • Small spot of each ink on separate labelled crosses on the same paper
  • Paper dipped in solvent in a covered beaker
  • Remove before the solvent reaches the top; mark solvent front
  • Compare number, colour and position of spots
  • Calculate Rf for each spot and compare
  • Same paper and solvent for all inks so they can be compared
  • Try another solvent if the ink does not move / safety with flammable solvent
How it is marked
  • 5-6 marks: a clear method that would give a fair comparison of all four inks on the same chromatogram, with Rf values and a clear way of deciding which pen matches.
  • 3-4 marks: a workable chromatography method, but with little about how the match is decided or some practical detail missing.
  • 1-2 marks: one or two relevant steps such as spotting ink on paper and putting it in water, with no logical order or comparison.

Revision notes: the method in full

Aim: To separate the coloured substances in inks or food colourings by paper chromatography, and to identify them by calculating Rf values.

Equipment

  • chromatography paper
  • pencil and ruler
  • capillary tubes or fine glass rods
  • food colouring samples, known and unknown
  • beaker (250 cm3)
  • water as the solvent
  • glass rod or split cork to hang the paper
  • lid or watch glass to cover the beaker
  • safety goggles

Method

  1. Draw a straight line in pencil about 2 cm from the bottom of the chromatography paper. This is the start line.
  2. Mark small pencil crosses along the line, about 1.5 cm apart, one for each sample.
  3. Use a capillary tube to put a small, concentrated spot of each sample on its cross. Let it dry and add another drop on the same spot.
  4. Pour water into the beaker to a depth of about 1 cm, so the start line will be above the water.
  5. Hang the paper in the beaker so the bottom edge dips into the water but the spots do not, and put a lid on.
  6. Leave the water to soak up the paper. Take the paper out when the solvent is near the top, and mark the solvent front with pencil straight away.
  7. Let the paper dry, then measure from the start line to the centre of each spot and to the solvent front.
  8. Calculate Rf = distance moved by spot / distance moved by solvent for each spot, and compare the unknown with the known samples.

Variables

  • Independent: The sample being tested (different food colourings).
  • Dependent: The distance moved by each spot, used to calculate its Rf value (measured with a ruler in cm).
  • Control: The solvent used; The type of paper; The temperature, and a lid on the beaker; The size of each spot and the height of the start line

Hazards

HazardWhat could happenHow to reduce the risk
Organic solvents if used instead of water (e.g. ethanol)Flammable vapour that could catch fireKeep away from flames and use a lid; water is the safer solvent for food colourings
Glass capillary tubesCan snap and cut the fingersHandle gently and put broken glass in the glass bin, not by hand

Key points

  • Draw the start line in pencil, not pen: ink would dissolve and run up the paper.
  • The start line must be above the solvent level, otherwise the spots dissolve into the solvent in the beaker.
  • Rf = distance moved by spot / distance moved by solvent; it has no unit and is always less than 1.
  • A pure substance gives one spot; a mixture gives two or more spots.
  • The same substance has the same Rf in the same solvent, so matching Rf values identify substances.
  • Measure to the centre of each spot, and mark the solvent front as soon as the paper is removed.

Every question and data set here is original and written by Robinson Tuition. Aligned to AQA Combined Science 8464 and AQA GCSE Chemistry 8462; this is not an exam-board paper and is not endorsed by AQA.