Aligned to AQA Combined Science 8464 and AQA GCSE Chemistry 8462
To find out how the volume of sodium hydroxide solution added to hydrochloric acid affects the temperature change of the neutralisation reaction.
14 original questions, 35 marks. Try each one, then open the model answer and mark yourself against the marking points. Or print the sheet and mark it with the answers sheet. The full method is in the revision notes at the bottom.
Equipment: polystyrene cup with a lid that has a hole for the thermometer; 250 cm3 beaker to hold the cup steady; thermometer (-10 to 50 °C, 0.1 °C divisions) or temperature probe; two 50 cm3 measuring cylinders; dilute hydrochloric acid; sodium hydroxide solution; glass stirring rod; safety goggles.
Zara added different volumes of sodium hydroxide solution to 25 cm3 portions of hydrochloric acid in a polystyrene cup, and recorded the highest temperature each time.
Volume of sodium hydroxide added in cm3
Starting temperature in °C
Highest temperature in °C
Temperature rise in °C
5
19.8
23.9
4.1
10
20.1
27.4
7.3
15
19.6
26.5
6.9
20
19.9
31.3
?
25
20.0
32.6
12.6
30
19.7
31.4
11.7
35
20.2
30.8
10.6
40
19.8
29.6
9.8
The questions
1
Name the independent variable and the dependent variable in Zara's investigation.
2 marks
Show the model answer
Independent: the volume of sodium hydroxide added. Dependent: the temperature rise.
Marking points
Independent: volume of sodium hydroxide
Dependent: temperature rise / highest temperature
2
Give one control variable and explain why it must be kept the same.
2 marks
Show the model answer
The volume of hydrochloric acid must be 25 cm3 each time. A different volume of acid would change how much reaction happens and how much liquid is heated, which would change the temperature rise.
Marking points
Valid control: volume or concentration of acid, concentration of alkali, cup type
Reason: it would also affect the temperature rise, so the test would not be fair
3
Explain why the reaction is done in a polystyrene cup with a lid instead of a glass beaker.
2 marks
Show the model answer
Polystyrene is a good thermal insulator and the lid stops warm air escaping, so less energy is lost to the surroundings. This means the temperature rise measured is closer to the true value.
Marking points
Polystyrene / lid reduce energy (heat) loss to the surroundings
So the measured temperature rise is more accurate / larger
4
Give one hazard in this practical and a way of reducing the risk.
2 marks
Show the model answer
Sodium hydroxide is an irritant and can damage the eyes if it splashes. Wear safety goggles and wash any spills off skin with plenty of water.
Marking points
Hazard: sodium hydroxide / acid irritant or corrosive, or glass thermometer breaking
Matching control: goggles, wash off, stir with a rod not the thermometer
5
Calculate the missing temperature rise for 20 cm3 of sodium hydroxide.
1 mark
Show the model answer
11.4 °C
Temperature rise = highest temperature - starting temperature
Temperature rise = 31.3 - 19.9 = 11.4 °C
Marking points
11.4 °C
6
Is the reaction between hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide exothermic or endothermic? Explain how the table shows this.
2 marks
Show the model answer
Exothermic. The temperature of the mixture went up every time, which shows the reaction transferred energy to the surroundings (the solution and the thermometer).
Marking points
Exothermic
Temperature rises, so energy is transferred to the surroundings
7
Identify the anomalous result and explain how you can tell.
2 marks
Show the model answer
The 15 cm3 result (6.9 °C). The temperature rise goes up steadily from 5 to 25 cm3, so it should be about 9 to 10 °C, but it is lower than the result for 10 cm3.
Marking points
15 cm3 / 6.9 °C
Does not fit the pattern: lower than the 10 cm3 result when it should be between 7.3 and 11.4
8
Describe the pattern in the temperature rise as more sodium hydroxide is added, and explain why it changes after 25 cm3.
3 marks
Show the model answer
The temperature rise increases from 5 cm3 to a maximum at 25 cm3, then decreases. Up to 25 cm3, more alkali means more acid reacts so more energy is released. At 25 cm3 all the acid has been neutralised, so extra sodium hydroxide does not react and just adds cooler liquid that has to be warmed, so the rise gets smaller.
Marking points
Rise increases to a peak at 25 cm3, then decreases
Before the peak, more acid reacts so more energy is released
After the peak, acid is used up; extra alkali does not react and absorbs energy / dilutes, so the rise falls
9
Zara repeated the 25 cm3 experiment twice more and got temperature rises of 12.9 °C and 12.4 °C. Calculate the mean temperature rise for 25 cm3, using all three results. Give your answer to 1 decimal place. Show your working.
3 marks
Show the model answer
12.6 °C
Total = 12.6 + 12.9 + 12.4 = 37.9 °C
Mean = 37.9 / 3 = 12.63...
Mean = 12.6 °C (1 decimal place)
Marking points
Adds all three: 12.6 + 12.9 + 12.4 = 37.9
Divides by 3
12.6 °C
10
Higher tier
The reaction between hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide is exothermic. Explain why, in terms of the energy needed to break bonds and the energy released when bonds are made.
3 marks
Show the model answer
Energy has to be taken in to break the bonds in the reactants, and energy is given out when the new bonds in the products are made. In this reaction more energy is released making the new bonds than is needed to break the old ones, so overall energy is transferred to the surroundings and the temperature rises.
Marking points
Breaking bonds takes in energy (endothermic)
Making bonds releases energy (exothermic)
More energy is released making bonds than is taken in breaking them, so the reaction is exothermic overall
11
Higher tier
Zara's results go up in steps of 5 cm3, so she cannot be sure that the peak is exactly at 25 cm3. Suggest how she could find the volume for the maximum temperature rise more precisely.
2 marks
Show the model answer
Do extra experiments with smaller steps close to the peak, such as 22, 23, 24, 26, 27 and 28 cm3. She could also plot two lines of best fit, one through the rising points and one through the falling points, and read off where they cross.
Marking points
More volumes with smaller intervals around 25 cm3
Or draw two lines of best fit and find where they intersect
12
Zara's thermometer has 0.1 °C divisions. Kai repeated the investigation with a thermometer that has only 1 °C divisions. Explain why Zara's results are better for comparing temperature rises, and give one further advantage of using a temperature probe and data logger.
3 marks
Show the model answer
Zara's thermometer has a higher resolution (0.1 °C instead of 1 °C), so she can measure small differences between results, such as her repeat rises of 12.4 °C and 12.9 °C, which Kai could not tell apart. A temperature probe and data logger records the temperature continuously, so the highest temperature is not missed while she is reading the scale.
Marking points
Zara's thermometer has the higher resolution (0.1 °C rather than 1 °C)
So small differences between temperature rises can be measured (more precise)
A probe and data logger records continuously, so the highest temperature is not missed
13
Zara's results are lower than the true values because some energy is always lost through the open top of the cup. Is this a random or a systematic error? Explain your answer.
2 marks
Show the model answer
It is a systematic error, because energy is lost in every experiment, so every temperature rise is too low in the same direction.
Marking points
Systematic error
It makes every result too low in the same way
14
When magnesium powder is added to copper(II) sulfate solution, the temperature rises. Plan an investigation to find out how the mass of magnesium powder affects the temperature rise.
6 marks
Show the model answer
Wear goggles. Stand a polystyrene cup in a beaker and add 25 cm3 of copper(II) sulfate solution, measured with a measuring cylinder. Put a thermometer through the lid and record the starting temperature. Weigh 0.10 g of magnesium powder on a balance, tip it into the cup, put the lid on and stir. Record the highest temperature reached and work out the rise. Rinse the cup and repeat with 0.20, 0.30, 0.40 and 0.50 g of magnesium, each time with fresh copper sulfate solution. Keep the volume and concentration of the solution and the type of cup the same, and start at room temperature. Repeat each mass three times and find the mean temperature rise, then plot a graph of mean temperature rise against mass of magnesium. Keep the magnesium away from flames as it is flammable.
Marking points (any 6, with the method in a logical order)
Fixed volume of copper(II) sulfate in a polystyrene cup with lid
Measure the starting temperature
Weigh a mass of magnesium on a balance
Add, stir and record the highest temperature
Temperature rise = highest - start
Repeat with at least 5 different masses
Control: volume and concentration of solution, cup, starting temperature
Repeat each mass and calculate a mean
Safety: goggles, magnesium powder kept away from flames
How it is marked
5-6 marks: a detailed, logical plan with insulated cup, start and highest temperature, a range of weighed masses, control variables and repeats that could give valid results.
3-4 marks: a reasonable plan covering measuring the temperature and changing the mass, but with missing detail such as no control variables or no repeats.
1-2 marks: some relevant points, such as adding magnesium and measuring temperature, but not organised into a method.
Revision notes: the method in full
Aim: To find out how the volume of sodium hydroxide solution added to hydrochloric acid affects the temperature change of the neutralisation reaction.
Equipment
polystyrene cup with a lid that has a hole for the thermometer
250 cm3 beaker to hold the cup steady
thermometer (-10 to 50 °C, 0.1 °C divisions) or temperature probe
two 50 cm3 measuring cylinders
dilute hydrochloric acid
sodium hydroxide solution
glass stirring rod
safety goggles
Method
Stand a polystyrene cup inside a beaker so it cannot tip over.
Use a measuring cylinder to add 25 cm3 of dilute hydrochloric acid to the cup.
Put the thermometer through the lid into the acid and record the starting temperature.
Measure 5 cm3 of sodium hydroxide solution in a second measuring cylinder.
Add the sodium hydroxide to the cup, put the lid on and stir.
Watch the thermometer and record the highest temperature reached.
Work out the temperature rise: highest temperature minus starting temperature.
Rinse and dry the cup, then repeat with 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, 35 and 40 cm3 of sodium hydroxide, each time with a fresh 25 cm3 of acid.
Repeat the whole set and calculate a mean temperature rise for each volume.
Variables
Independent: The volume of sodium hydroxide solution added.
Dependent: The temperature rise (highest temperature minus starting temperature), measured with a thermometer.
Control: Volume of hydrochloric acid (25 cm3); Concentration of the acid and of the alkali; Type of cup, with a lid, each time; Starting temperature of the solutions (room temperature)
Hazards
Hazard
What could happen
How to reduce the risk
Sodium hydroxide solution
Irritant or corrosive to eyes and skin
Wear safety goggles; wash splashes off immediately with water
Dilute hydrochloric acid
Irritates eyes and cuts in the skin
Wear goggles and handle with care
Glass thermometer
Can break and cut the hand if used to stir
Stir with a glass rod, not the thermometer, and keep the cup inside a beaker so it does not tip
Key points
Record the highest temperature reached, not the temperature after a fixed time.
Temperature rise = highest temperature - starting temperature; this allows for different starting temperatures.
A polystyrene cup with a lid reduces energy lost to the surroundings, because polystyrene is a good insulator.
A temperature rise means an exothermic reaction; a fall means endothermic.
The biggest rise is when the acid and alkali exactly neutralise; adding more alkali after that just cools the mixture down.
Stir so that the whole mixture reaches the same temperature.
Every question and data set here is original and written by Robinson Tuition. Aligned to AQA Combined Science 8464 and AQA GCSE Chemistry 8462; this is not an exam-board paper and is not endorsed by AQA.